24" iMac and BootCamp - Your experience, Getting the 24" to boot to Windows

[Flyinace2000]

Just wondering if you have had an new information regading te 24" iMac and bootcamp. I am running a 24" and have not been able to get the internal monitor to work with windows. Check out these other threads

http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=240531

http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?t...=0&tstart=0

HardMac Help Us!!!

-Will

[linathael]

Just wondering if you have had an new information regading te 24" iMac and bootcamp. I am running a 24" and have not been able to get the internal monitor to work with windows. Check out these other threads

http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=240531

http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?t...=0&tstart=0

HardMac Help Us!!!

-Will

hello
we do not have more information that those collected in the different topics on macrumors and apple forum.
information collected on our french forum : http://forum.macbidouille.com/index.php?sh...p=1943849&#

After having read all topics on different forum; some things seem not to have been considered:
- trying to install XP from an external drive.
- have you tried to change display resolution priori launching Windows installation?
- is it a true windows installation disk or a copy?
- have you tried to wait something like 30 minutes while you get the black screen? as we have reported it in a recent article on how to install 4 OSes on the Mac Pro, such lag phase during installation have already been noticed: http://www.hardmac.com/articles/63/
- is the problem present when trying to install XP AND Vista, or is it windows version-specific?
- last but not least (for the moment) try to collect serial number of those iMac G4 that seems to be affected by this problem.

[dobermann]

Hi there.

It works for me.
24 iMac 256vram, 2Gb, 500HD

BUT

If windows crashes, which games causes it a lot. Or if I restart directly from OS X, the display shows a lot of garbage. The first time I thought I've blown up my iMac or something like that.
So to use windows, I turn off the computer, wait a bit.. (god I hate waiting for computers...) and then turn it on.
I use windows for games and this computer is handling every one I throw at it beautifully.

regards
gorka

[linathael]

Hi there.

It works for me.
24 iMac 256vram, 2Gb, 500HD

BUT

If windows crashes, which games causes it a lot. Or if I restart directly from OS X, the display shows a lot of garbage. The first time I thought I've blown up my iMac or something like that.
So to use windows, I turn off the computer, wait a bit.. (god I hate waiting for computers...) and then turn it on.
I use windows for games and this computer is handling every one I throw at it beautifully.

regards
gorka

you have been using XP SP2 correct?
what is the serial of your iMac?
thanks for your comments

[dobermann]

Hi there.

It works for me.
24 iMac 256vram, 2Gb, 500HD

BUT

If windows crashes, which games causes it a lot. Or if I restart directly from OS X, the display shows a lot of garbage. The first time I thought I've blown up my iMac or something like that.
So to use windows, I turn off the computer, wait a bit.. (god I hate waiting for computers...) and then turn it on.
I use windows for games and this computer is handling every one I throw at it beautifully.

regards
gorka

you have been using XP SP2 correct?
what is the serial of your iMac?
thanks for your comments

XP SP2
The serial is W863932NVGP
Let me know what you find.

regards
gorka

[linathael]

Just wondering if you have had an new information regading te 24" iMac and bootcamp. I am running a 24" and have not been able to get the internal monitor to work with windows. Check out these other threads

http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=240531

http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?t...=0&tstart=0

HardMac Help Us!!!

-Will

I am back with some solutions to be tested:
- Catalyst drivers from ATI : http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?t...15&tstart=0
- Apple Cinema Display HID driver and control panel for Windows XP.
http://sourceforge.net/projects/winacd

[Flyinace2000]

Just wondering if you have had an new information regading te 24" iMac and bootcamp. I am running a 24" and have not been able to get the internal monitor to work with windows. Check out these other threads

http://forums.macrumors.com/showthread.php?t=240531

http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?t...=0&tstart=0

HardMac Help Us!!!

-Will

hello
we do not have more information that those collected in the different topics on macrumors and apple forum.
information collected on our french forum : http://forum.macbidouille.com/index.php?sh...p=1943849&#

After having read all topics on different forum; some things seem not to have been considered:
- trying to install XP from an external drive.
- have you tried to change display resolution priori launching Windows installation?
- is it a true windows installation disk or a copy?
- have you tried to wait something like 30 minutes while you get the black screen? as we have reported it in a recent article on how to install 4 OSes on the Mac Pro, such lag phase during installation have already been noticed: http://www.hardmac.com/articles/63/
- is the problem present when trying to install XP AND Vista, or is it windows version-specific?
- last but not least (for the moment) try to collect serial number of those iMac G4 that seems to be affected by this problem.

-Do you mean install XP using an external CD/DVD drive or install it to an external hard drive?
-I have not tried that.
-i have tried both, original SP2 disc and my slipstreamed SP2 disc
-I havenot tried waiting that long
-I will try Vista this week
-iMac G4? do you mean 24?

[linathael]

-Do you mean install XP using an external CD/DVD drive or install it to an external hard drive?
-I have not tried that.
-i have tried both, original SP2 disc and my slipstreamed SP2 disc
-I havenot tried waiting that long
-I will try Vista this week
-iMac G4? do you mean 24?

I meant iMac Intel

concerning external drive, it could be both (optical drive or HD containing the image of SP2)

you should try to wait about 30 minutes only to be sure that what we have seen as lag phase during installation in our article is not simply repeating the same way for you.

Did you look at the last hints I have psoted concerning drivers?

Have you tried to start up from a LinuxCD (knoppix CD for example), simply to be sure that it is not a problem with the optical drive firmware.

hear from you soon

[cheerful]

will the updated bootcamp be able to solve the issue?

[linathael]

will the updated bootcamp be able to solve the issue?

not sure, it is not mentioned in the lsit of functions or bug fixes...
but it is worth trying I think

[Ridcully]

Just saw your post over in the Apple forums (I'm KevinBrahl1) and thought I'd add my experience.

24" iMac/2gb RAM/7600GT 256/250 gb HDD
Windows XP SP2 Retail

Basically seeing what everyone with this problem is reporting. iMac boots with the Windows XP disc but you can't see anything but a blank screen, and the screen isn't "off", it's blank. I say that because it is a slightly lighter shade of black than when the screen is actually not on. Anyway, I can hear the iMac boot and I know it's doing something because when I arrow up/down I can hear it churn away. If I knew the XP install routine I could probably do it blindfolded but I don't have enough experience to guess which step is which.

Using an external monitor also does not work for me. I've tried booting with my 20" Acer LCD connected, I've tried plugging it into the iMac AFTER it has booted to the cd and neither way has worked. The LCD just says "No Signal" and goes blank.

I have tried waiting for at least 15 minutes after bootup. I can't imagine that waiting any longer will help but I'm willing to try anything.

I don't know how to make a slipstreamed disk. I assume you put the latest drivers on there and then boot from it? I do have a PC I can use, I just don't know how to do it.

Thanks in advance for any help!

[linathael]

Thanks

- did you try to boot from another WinXP CD/DVD?
- did you try to boot from a LinuxCD?
- Did you reinstall Tiger when you got your iMac, or have you kept the pre-install version?

[jrids]

Right - before anyone says that I'm doing something wrong..... I would like to add that I'm not!

I too have an iMac 24" which I purchased over a month ago. It is experiencing these same black screen issues upon the Windows XP setup. Apple will fix this, it’s juts a matter of time. My thoughts are still that BootCamp is BETA and by next spring when 10.5 is released it will support ALL Intel based Macs (It has to otherwise Apple will need to dish out a lot of refunds). Until then, it’s just a waiting game.

I have been monitoring a lot of posts across many websites regarding this issue, in fact I was one of the early ones to find it ad report back. Just be patient.

Apple have done a good job covering themselves with this by stating to their staff (and clearly on their website) that they DO NOT SUPPORT WINDOWS or the BETA version of BootCamp so asking for a replacement machine is really up to Apple’s discretion.

My advice would be fire an e-mail to "bootcamp@apple.com" stating your machines serial and hardware config and possibly your firmware version (It all helps).

I am in the same boat as all of you and I am too very frustrated. I will be starting my own blog regarding this very soon to try and find out which serials (or range of serials) are affected.

I will keep you all updated if I find out any more.

James.
ACSA/MCSE

[linathael]

Could you provide the serial number of your iMac 24"?

a team member has a iMAc24" too, and apparently everything is fine for him, we could look at serial, because I think it might explain some things out there.

[Ridcully]

Thanks

- did you try to boot from another WinXP CD/DVD?
- did you try to boot from a LinuxCD?
- Did you reinstall Tiger when you got your iMac, or have you kept the pre-install version?

- I don't have another WinXP CD/DVD to try
- I don't have a LinuxCD
- The first thing I do with every new Mac I buy is reinstall the OS

Actually, I tried installing XP as soon as I took it out of the box, THEN I reinstalled the OS hoping that that would make a difference. Also, I tried XP with 10.4.7 and 10.4.8.

I'm not at my Mac atm so I can't give you my serial, but I will when I get home.

Oh, and I tried waiting again today. Let it sit for over an hour. Nothing.

[linathael]

after reading Apple forum, it turns out that one user could not even reinstall OSX on its iMac after WinXP installation failed. The optical drive is not recognized anymore, or can not force to boot from it anymore.

[jrids]

Could you provide the serial number of your iMac 24"?

a team member has a iMAc24" too, and apparently everything is fine for him, we could look at serial, because I think it might explain some things out there.

My iMac s/n: W86361TXVGN
Spec is: 2.16MHz/1GB/7300GT

I contacted Applecare today, I already knew what the answer would be ("don't know sir"). I was indeed correct. I did point out the recent posts and forums dedicated to this issue but speaking to the front line staff is a waste of time, I would like to speak to the developers!

Can we possibly setup a database to store s/n of affected iMacs? I believe this issue only occurs on units that were purchased shortly after the 24" model was released as I had one of the first units my supplier managed to get hold of.

James.

[linathael]

Can we possibly setup a database to store s/n of affected iMacs? I believe this issue only occurs on units that were purchased shortly after the 24" model was released as I had one of the first units my supplier managed to get hold of.

James.

you can start collecting the serial from this topic, there is not problem with that:
simply get the serials as a quote and add yours:
something like:

Not working iMac:
Ridcully: 24" iMac/2gb RAM/7600GT 256/250 gb HDD
jrids: W86361TXVGN - 24" iMac/2.16MHz/1GB/7300GT


working iMac:
Dobermann: W863932NVGP - 24" iMac 256vram, 2Gb, 500HD

[Sonyc91]

Same problem here. Haven't tried to boot from Mac OS X DVD, I hope mine isn't broken as I can read in the topic

Not working iMac:
Ridcully: 24" iMac/2gb RAM/7600GT 256/250 gb HDD
jrids: W86361TXVGN - 24" iMac/2.16MHz/1GB/7300GT
Sonyc91 : W86381ALVG- 24" iMac/2.16GHz/2GB/7600GT/500Gb HDD/10.4.8/1.10f2


working iMac:
Dobermann: W863932NVGP - 24" iMac 256vram, 2Gb, 500HD

This post has been edited by Sonyc91: Nov 2 2006, 03:00 PM

[linathael]

Not working iMac:
Ridcully: 24" iMac/2gb RAM/7600GT 256/250 gb HDD
jrids: W86361TXVGN - 24" iMac/2.16MHz/1GB/7300GT
Sonyc91 : W86381ALVG- 24" iMac/2.16GHz/2GB/7600GT/500Gb HDD/10.4.8/1.10f2


working iMac:
Dobermann: W863932NVGP - 24" iMac 256vram, 2Gb, 500HD

we need more numbers, but the serial looks similar for the numerical part (W+5 digit, instead of W+6 digit)... is the the beginning of a hint??

[Kalomir]

Hope it is.
Being the aforementioned team member, I'll check my S/N tonight. I guess this would require a news item.

[Ridcully]

Ok, here's my serial:

Not working iMac
Ridcully - W86372UPVGP - 24" iMac 2.33ghz / 2gb RAM / 7600GT 256 / 250 gb HDD

This post has been edited by Ridcully: Nov 2 2006, 04:49 PM

[linathael]

hereafter is the update serial list
please add your serial by quoting this message, then directly insert your information between quotes.
Thanks

Not working iMac:
Ridcully: W86372UPVGP - 24" iMac 2.33ghz / 2gb RAM / 7600GT 256 / 250 gb HDD
jrids: W86361TXVGN - 24" iMac/2.16MHz/1GB/7300GT
Sonyc91 : W86381ALVG- 24" iMac/2.16GHz/2GB/7600GT/500Gb HDD/10.4.8/1.10f2


working iMac:
Dobermann: W863932NVGP - 24" iMac 256vram, 2Gb, 500HD

[Kalomir]

Not working iMac:
Ridcully: W86372UPVGP - 24" iMac 2.33ghz / 2gb RAM / 7600GT 256 / 250 gb HDD
jrids: W86361TXVGN - 24" iMac/2.16MHz/1GB/7300GT
Sonyc91 : W86381ALVG- 24" iMac/2.16GHz/2GB/7600GT/500Gb HDD/10.4.8/1.10f2


working iMac:
Dobermann: W863932NVGP - 24" iMac 256vram, 2Gb, 500HD
Kalomir: W86373BAVGP - - 24" iMac/2.33GHz/2GB/7600GT/500Gb HDD/10.4.7

[linathael]

We need to get more serial numbers to make it valuable.

I also think one will need to get additional information concerning the optical drive sitting in the non compatible BootCamp iMac (might be different manufacturer or firmware).
Should also look at GPU firmware, puzzling that iMac with different GPU are equally affected

we are going to publish an update:

it seems that there are 2 different SMC versions for the iMac24":
In France so far, the status seems to follow this rule:
- 1.10f1 => blank display
- 1.10f2 => Windows works

[Gregorito75]

We need to get more serial numbers to make it valuable.

I also think one will need to get additional information concerning the optical drive sitting in the non compatible BootCamp iMac (might be different manufacturer or firmware).
Should also look at GPU firmware, puzzling that iMac with different GPU are equally affected

we are going to publish an update:

it seems that there are 2 different SMC versions for the iMac24":
In France so far, the status seems to follow this rule:
- 1.10f1 => blank display
- 1.10f2 => Windows works

Hey all!
I've came across this topic in neverending quest to see if anyone has been able to find a fix for Windows booting problems. Hate to break it for you, but my iMac is an exception to SMC rule here. My SMS verion is 1.10f2, but Windows will not install (withouth external monitor, does not work w/o it though). I have iMac CTO iMac 24, 2.33Ghz, NVidia 7600GT 256, serial W86391MGVGP

[Sonyc91]

it seems that there are 2 different SMC versions for the iMac24":
In France so far, the status seems to follow this rule:
- 1.10f1 => blank display
- 1.10f2 => Windows works

As you can read in the recap, mine is 1.10f2, but doesn't work ... Is it a mistake in your message ?

[paris5]

Not working iMac:
Ridcully: W86372UPVGP - 24" iMac 2.33ghz / 2gb RAM / 7600GT 256 / 250 gb HDD
jrids: W86361TXVGN - 24" iMac/2.16MHz/1GB/7300GT
Sonyc91 : W86381ALVG- 24" iMac/2.16GHz/2GB/7600GT/500Gb HDD/10.4.8/1.10f2
paris5: W863764RVGN - 24" iMac/2.16Ghz/2GB/7300GT/250HD/10.4.8/1.10f2


working iMac:
Dobermann: W863932NVGP - 24" iMac 256vram, 2Gb, 500HD
Kalomir: W86373BAVGP - - 24" iMac/2.33GHz/2GB/7600GT/500Gb HDD/10.4.7

it seems that there are 2 different SMC versions for the iMac24":
In France so far, the status seems to follow this rule:
- 1.10f1 => blank display
- 1.10f2 => Windows works

As you can read in the recap, mine is 1.10f2, but doesn't work ... Is it a mistake in your message ?

I confirm mine is 1.10f2 as well and in the not working category.

[chevy]

Not working iMac:
Ridcully: W86372UPVGP - 24" iMac/2.33 GHz/2 GB/7600GT 256/250 GB
jrids: W86361TXVGN - 24" iMac/2.16 GHz/1 GB/7300GT
Sonyc91 : W86381ALVG - 24" iMac/2.16 GHz/2 GB/7600GT/500 GB/10.4.8/1.10f2
paris5: W863764RVGN - 24" iMac/2.16 Ghz/2 GB/7300GT/250 GB/10.4.8/1.10f2


working iMac:
Dobermann: W863932NVGP - 24" iMac 256 vram/2 GB/500 GB
Kalomir: W86373BAVGP - 24" iMac/2.33 GHz/2 GB/7600GT/500 GB/10.4.7
Chevy: W863711PVGP - 24" iMac/2.16 GHz/2 GB/7600GT/250 GB/10.4.8/1.10f2

it seems that there are 2 different SMC versions for the iMac24":
In France so far, the status seems to follow this rule:
- 1.10f1 => blank display
- 1.10f2 => Windows works

As you can read in the recap, mine is 1.10f2, but doesn't work ... Is it a mistake in your message ?

I confirm mine is 1.10f2 as well and in the not working category.

[jrids]

Not working iMac:
Ridcully: W86372UPVGP - 24" iMac/2.33 GHz/2 GB/7600GT 256/250 GB
jrids: W86361TXVGN - 24" iMac/2.16 GHz/1 GB/7300GT
Sonyc91 : W86381ALVG - 24" iMac/2.16 GHz/2 GB/7600GT/500 GB/10.4.8/1.10f2
paris5: W863764RVGN - 24" iMac/2.16 Ghz/2 GB/7300GT/250 GB/10.4.8/1.10f2


working iMac:
Dobermann: W863932NVGP - 24" iMac 256 vram/2 GB/500 GB
Kalomir: W86373BAVGP - 24" iMac/2.33 GHz/2 GB/7600GT/500 GB/10.4.7
Chevy: W863711PVGP - 24" iMac/2.16 GHz/2 GB/7600GT/250 GB/10.4.8/1.10f2

it seems that there are 2 different SMC versions for the iMac24":
In France so far, the status seems to follow this rule:
- 1.10f1 => blank display
- 1.10f2 => Windows works

As you can read in the recap, mine is 1.10f2, but doesn't work ... Is it a mistake in your message ?

I confirm mine is 1.10f2 as well and in the not working category.

My SMC version is 1.10f2 as also does not work - As stated above.